Guide

Open cell vs closed cell spray foam: which to spray where

Open cell is light and lets moisture through. Closed cell is dense and rigid, with more R per inch. Spray open cell in deep walls above ground, and closed cell where depth is short or water is a risk.

Open vs closed cell

Industry ranges from the Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance.

  • Open cell
  • Closed cell
  • R-value per inch

    1. Open cell:

      R-3.6 to R-4.5

    2. Closed cell:

      R-5.8 to R-6.9

  • Density

    1. Open cell:

      0.5 to 0.8 lb/ft³

    2. Closed cell:

      1.8 to 2.3 lb/ft³

  • Thickness that stops air

    1. Open cell:

      About 3.5 to 5.5 in

    2. Closed cell:

      About 1.5 in

Foams side by side

Diagram of open cell foam, with broken cells that let vapor through, beside closed cell foam, with sealed cells that stop air and resist moisture

Where each foam goes

Ratings for cold climates from the U.S. Department of Energy's Building America spray foam guide.

  • Walls above ground: Either foam is preferred, and open cell works best at full wall depth.
  • Rim joists and sill plates: Closed cell is preferred, and open cell is acceptable.
  • Basements and crawl spaces: Closed cell is preferred, and open cell is not acceptable.
  • Unvented attics and roof decks: Closed cell is preferred, and open cell is acceptable.

For what we carry for each job, see spray foam insulation.

The foams we carry

Green Valley's open cell is GVP 500 OC No Mix and its closed cell is GVP 2.0. The kit foam is Handi-Foam E84. See spray foam insulation and Handi-Foam kits.

  • Green Valley open cell
  • Handi-Foam kit
  • Green Valley closed cell
  • Density

    1. Green Valley open cell:

      0.50 lb/ft³

    2. Handi-Foam kit:

      1.75 lb/ft³

    3. Green Valley closed cell:

      2.0 lb/ft³

  • R-value per inch

    1. Green Valley open cell:

      R-3.9 per in

    2. Handi-Foam kit:

      R-6.1 at 1 inR-11.7 at 2 in

    3. Green Valley closed cell:

      R-7.2 per in

Maker data sheets, with R-values measured after 180 days.

Moisture and air tests
  • Moisture: GVP 500 OC, 7.54 perms at 3.5 in; Handi-Foam E84, 1.4 perms at 1.5 in; GVP 2.0, Class II at 1.1 in.
  • Air: GVP 500 OC, under 0.02 L/s·m² at 3.5 in; Handi-Foam E84, 1 in or more; GVP 2.0, under 0.004 cfm/ft² at 1 in.
  • Kit density: the 1.75 lb/ft³ is measured with the foam left to free rise.

What an attic needs

In cold zones, the code wants unvented attic foam to slow moisture, alone or under a coating or cover.

Closed cell does not always do that alone. Handi-Foam's kit foam needs the coating.

Code text and coatings
  • Rule: IRC R806.5 (2021, 2024) in zones 5 to 8 requires air-impermeable attic foam to be Class II or have a Class II coating or covering.
  • Covering: in direct contact with the foam's underside, and only over foams its report lists.
  • Open cell sprayed air-impermeable falls under the same wording; ask your building department.
  • No-Burn Plus ThB: not Class II (ER-305). FireShell F10E: Class III (ESR-3997).
  • Class III means over 1.0 up to 10 perms; check the data sheet at your thickness.

Attic R-value minimums

The least foam R-value against the roof deck in an unvented attic.

  1. Zone 5B

    R-20Front Range

  2. Zone 6B

    R-25Eagle and Chaffee counties

  3. Zone 7

    R-30Clear Creek, Summit, Grand, Park and Lake counties

From the 2021 and 2024 codes. The edition your town adopted, local changes and your permit date decide: Colorado Energy Office adoption map.

Table and energy code
  • Source: Table R806.5, IRC 2021 and 2024.
  • Counts toward the energy-code R-value, not instead of it; foam alone (item 5.1.1) follows the energy code.
  • The data sheet and evaluation report set pass thickness and wait time.

Bare foam limits

Rim joists, sill plates and headers can skip the thermal barrier (the drywall or coating over foam) within these limits:

  • Thickness

    3-1/4in or less

  • Handi-Foam kit thickness

    2in or less

    Kit foam

  • Density

    0.5 to 2.0lb/ft³

    Sprayed foam

  • Fire ratings

    25 / 450or less

    Flame spread / smoke

Everywhere else, cover the foam. See spray foam insulation.

Code sections
  • Rim joist exception: IRC R316.5.11 (R303.5.11 in 2024).
  • Kit cap: the 2 in limit for Handi-Foam E84 is in ESR-2717.

Frequently asked questions

Can I mix open cell and closed cell on one job?

Yes, in different places. Ask the foam maker before layering both in one wall.

How thick should spray foam be in an attic?

Enough inches to reach the attic minimum above, using the foam's R-value per inch. The code R-values still apply.

Can I spray foam in a Colorado winter?

Keep the chemical warm and the surface free of frost; ICP's temperatures are on Handi-Foam kits.

Picked your foam?

Send where it goes, the area and the target R-value for a quote.

Call us:+1 (720) 502-6469

Same-day and next-day delivery on most products across the Front Range. Delivered from Denver.

Request a quote

Tell us what you need and we will reply with availability and pricing.